Black Cat Facts: Adoption Myths and What Studies Show
- Black Cats at a Glance
- Do Black Cats Take Longer to Be Adopted?
- What the Colorado State University Study Found
- What Cats Protection Reports
- What One Indiana Shelter Found
- Why the Numbers Do Not Agree
- Common Black Cat Myths
- "Black Cats Are Bad Luck"
- "Black Cats Are Boring"
- "Black Cats Look Bad in Photos"
- If You Are Thinking of Adopting a Black Cat
- Looking for a Black Cat Name?
- Common Mistakes When Thinking About Black Cats
- Conclusion
Note: This article is for informational purposes only and does not replace professional veterinary advice.
Quick Answer
Black cats may wait a few days longer for a home at some shelters and not at others. Colorado State University and Cats Protection found longer waits while one Indiana shelter found almost none. Bad luck and boring are myths according to Cats Protection so choose the individual cat and not the coat colour.
Are black cats really adopted more slowly, and are any of the old stories about them true? The honest answer is that the research is mixed. Two charity and university sources say black cats wait a little longer for a home, one shelter's own data shows almost no gap, and nothing we found supports the idea that a cat's coat colour says anything bad about the cat. This guide sets out what each source actually found, why the numbers do not agree, and what that means if you are thinking of adopting a black cat.
Black Cats at a Glance
- Bad luck is a myth. Cats Protection, a UK cat charity, calls the claims that black cats are boring, bad luck or look bad in selfies "total myths".
- The adoption gap is real in some studies and not in others. Colorado State University researchers and Cats Protection found longer waits. One Indiana shelter found almost none.
- The gaps are small. The longer waits reported are measured in days, not months.
- Photos may matter. One researcher said black cats do not photograph as well, so bright and well-lit pictures may help them get noticed.
- You are choosing a cat, not a colour. Age and personality of the individual cat matter more than the coat.
Do Black Cats Take Longer to Be Adopted?
This is the question most people search for, and the sources give different answers.
What the Colorado State University Study Found
Researchers at Colorado State University studied nine years of adoption records from the Larimer Humane Society in Fort Collins and 18 years of records from the Dumb Friends League in Denver. Their paper is titled "Cats in Animal Shelters: Exploring the Common Perception that Black Cats Take Longer to Adopt". The university reported that adult black cats needed about three more days to be adopted, and that black cats took four to six more days to be adopted than cats of other colours. It said the pattern held for both adult and juvenile cats.
The lead researcher said she could not be certain that myths about black cats cause the longer stays. She noted that people link white with "good" and black with "bad", and that this may play a role.
What Cats Protection Reports
Cats Protection launched National Black Cat Day on 27 October 2011 after finding that black and black-and-white cats in its care took on average seven days longer to find a home than cats of other colours. Two posts from October 2015 gave figures of 13 per cent longer and about a week longer. Its 2020 history of the day says that black cats then spent ten days less in its care before being rehomed than they did 10 years earlier, and that in 2019 black cats took only two more days on average to find a home than cats of other colours. So the same charity's own figure shrank from about a week to about two days over that period.
What One Indiana Shelter Found
A 2021 report on the Bloomington Animal Shelter in Indiana described data from 2017 onward. It found that 55.6 per cent of black cats were adopted compared with 57.3 per cent of cats of other colours, a gap of fewer than two cats in 100. The median time in the shelter was 22.3 days for black cats and 22.4 days for other cats. The shelter's outreach coordinator said she believed the myth used to be true. That is her opinion and not something the data proves.
Why the Numbers Do Not Agree
Precaution: these sources conflict. They come from different shelters, countries and years, and they measure different things (days to adoption, percentage of cats adopted, median time). We have not found one study that covers all shelters, so treat each figure as a snapshot of that shelter and not as a rule. What all three sources agree on is that any difference is measured in days and not in months.
Common Black Cat Myths
"Black Cats Are Bad Luck"
Cats Protection says plainly that this is a myth. In 2015 it also noted that the belief seemed to be taking hold with younger people.
"Black Cats Are Boring"
Cats Protection staff describe black and black-and-white cats as just as funny and sweet as any other cat and as just as deserving of a loving home. This is the charity's view from caring for large numbers of cats. It is not a scientific study of personality by coat colour, and we did not find one, so do not read it as proof that every black cat has any particular character.
"Black Cats Look Bad in Photos"
The Colorado State researcher said black cats simply do not photograph as well and suggested that shelters promote them more positively. Cats Protection lists "look bad in selfies" among its myths. Both can be partly right: a dark coat is harder to photograph well, which is a practical problem, but it says nothing about the cat.
If You Are Thinking of Adopting a Black Cat
The sources point to a few practical things.
- Look past the photo. If a shelter picture is dark or blurry, ask to meet the cat. A cat that photographs badly may still be the best match for you.
- Judge the individual. Ask staff about the cat's history and how it behaves with people and other animals.
- Prepare the home the same way as for any cat. Our guide to introducing a new cat to your home covers the first weeks.
- Not sure which cat suits you? See our guide to choosing a cat as a first-time owner before you visit a shelter.
- Shy cats take time. If your new cat hides, read why cats hide.
Cats Protection holds National Black Cat Day each year on 27 October to help celebrate black cats. It was created in 2011 when black cats were waiting longer for homes.
Looking for a Black Cat Name?
Our free Cat Name Generator lets you pick a coat colour such as black and mixes in colour-themed names. It is a hand-picked list that you can shuffle and save to your own browser.
Common Mistakes When Thinking About Black Cats
- Treating one shelter's numbers as if they apply to every shelter.
- Judging a cat only from a dark photograph.
- Assuming that a coat colour tells you how a cat will behave.
- Believing superstition over what animal charities say about black cats.
Conclusion
Black cats may wait a few days longer for a home at some shelters and not at others, and the research does not settle why. The charity's own figures suggest the gap has narrowed over time. What the sources do agree on is that the old superstitions are myths and that a cat should be chosen as an individual. If you meet a black cat that suits your home, the coat colour is no reason to walk away. Try the Cat Name Generator on PetNurture once you have found yours.
This guide is for general education and is not a substitute for advice from a licensed veterinarian. If you are worried about your cat's health or behaviour, contact a licensed veterinarian.
Medical Disclaimer
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered veterinary, medical, behavioral, or training advice. While we strive for accuracy, we make no guarantees regarding completeness or results. Always consult a licensed veterinarian or qualified pet care professional before making decisions about your petβs health, diet, or behavior.
AI Illustration Notice
Some images in this article may have been generated or enhanced using artificial intelligence for illustrative purposes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Should I Do Next?
A general decision guide β always use your own judgement and contact a veterinarian for anything beyond routine care.
- Meet the cat in person Do not rely on a dark photograph. Ask staff if you can spend time with the cat.
- Ask about the cat's history Ask how the cat behaves with people and other animals and how long it has been at the shelter.
- Prepare your home Set up a quiet room and the basics before the cat arrives.
- Contact a licensed veterinarian Book a first check-up and ask any health questions about your new cat.
Common Mistakes
- Treating one shelter's numbers as if they apply to every shelter
- Judging a cat only from a dark photograph
- Assuming a coat colour tells you how a cat will behave
- Believing superstition over what animal charities say about black cats
Prevention Tips
- Visit and meet several cats before you decide
- Ask staff about each cat's personality and history
- Look past a poor quality photograph
- Prepare a quiet space at home before the cat arrives
Picture a shelter with two cats side by side. The photo of the black cat is dark and blurry so most visitors scroll past. A visitor who asks to meet both finds that the black cat walks straight up to say hello and takes it home.
Practical Checklist
- Meet the cat in person before deciding
- Ask staff about the cat's history and behaviour
- Set up a quiet room at home
- Book a check-up with a licensed veterinarian
- Pick a name you both like
Editorial Note
This article is part of PetNurture's educational library.
Topics draw on publicly available educational resources, recognised veterinary organisations, academic publications and established animal welfare references where appropriate.
The specific sources this article draws on are listed in its References section. If you spot an error, please let us know.
References
The information in this article has been reviewed and supported using the following sources.
Colorado State University
Colorado State University study: cats with black coats stay longer in shelters
Reports nine years of Larimer Humane Society data and 18 years of Dumb Friends League data; adult black cats took about three more days and black cats four to six more days than other colours; researcher cannot say myths cause the gap.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Cats Protection
Black cats: five common misconceptions
27 October 2015. Calls the claims that black cats look bad in selfies and are boring or bad luck total myths; says black cats in its care take 13 per cent longer to be adopted.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Cats Protection
History of National Black Cat Day
27 October 2020. Says the day launched on 27 October 2011 when black cats took a week longer on average to find a home; they now spend ten days less in care than 10 years ago; in 2019 black cats took only two more days than other colours.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Cats Protection
Says National Black Cat Day is held each year on 27 October and created in 2011; black and black-and-white cats took on average seven days longer to find a home when the campaign launched.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Cats Protection
26 October 2015. Says black cats take on average a week longer to find a home, that the bad luck myth seems to be taking hold with younger people, and that black cats are just as deserving.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Indiana Daily Student
Are black cats adopted less often? Bloomington Animal Shelter data
2021. Reports 55.6 per cent of black cats adopted versus 57.3 per cent of other cats and a median stay of 22.3 versus 22.4 days at one shelter.
Accessed Nov 4, 2026
Pet Emergency Guidance
Every pet is unique. If your pet exhibits severe symptoms, sudden behavioral changes, or a medical emergency, do not rely on online guides β contact a licensed veterinarian or emergency clinic immediately.
Was this article helpful?
About PetNurture
PetNurture is an educational library of pet care guides, interactive tools and practical resources for pet parents. We work continuously to keep our content accurate and up to date. Reader feedback helps us maintain content quality.
Popular Cat Guides
Cat Name Generator
Generate girl, boy and cute cat names by style and coat colour, with naming tips.